Why Are Indian Women So Stressed Out?

Women in urban India have easy access to domestic help: A full-time maid, cook or driver are not uncommon in their households. Of course, these are luxuries that most working women in the rest of the world can only dream about.

But a recent survey by global research firm Nielsen illuminates another picture. Covering 6,500 women across 21 developed and developing countries, the study’s results show that women in India are the most stressed out. Of the respondents in India, 87% said they felt stressed most of the time. They are followed by women in Mexico (74%), Russia (69%), Spain (66%), France (65%) and Italy (64%). In the U.S., the number is at 53%.     

What exactly is weighing on women in one of the fastest growing economies in the world? The Nielsen survey’s respondents point to the requirement of managing multiple roles.

One could well argue that this particular condition exists for women across the globe: Juggling roles at home and work are a given. There is a difference in India, however, says Nirmala Menon, founder and CEO of Interweave Consulting, a Bangalore-based firm that focuses on diversity management and inclusiveness in the workplace. Menon notes that even as career opportunities for women in India are on the upswing, the support structure and social mores have not kept pace. “Nor has the internal psyche of the Indian woman,” adds Menon. “Despite ‘modern’ times, traditional expectations of women are still conveyed in subtle but consistent ways. The Indian woman has far more familial interfaces to manage than her western counterpart.”

According to Hema Ravichandar, human resources advisor and formerly the global head of HR at IT firm Infosys: “Regressive mindsets in society and the workplace; a culture that rewards performance based on effort — with the number of hours spent [working] as proxy indicator — rather than result; rigid work policies which do not factor in the need to spend extra time at home during critical phases like childbirth, adoption, etc., are unique to India.”

There are other reasons, too. Technical infrastructure support and enablers are at a nascent stage in the country as compared to the developed economies. Options like working from home, flex-time, telecommuting and so on have arrived only in the recent past in new industries and are still evolving. “Even in companies which have these facilities, it is not construed as the right thing to do if you are serious about going up the corporate ladder,” says Ravichandar.

A lack of women in executive roles mirrors this. A report by Standard Chartered Bank points out that women constitute only 5.3% of the total number of board members in the top 100 Indian companies by market capitalization on the Bombay Stock Exchange. This is much lower than in other countries, including Australia (8.3%), Hong Kong (8.9%), the U.K. (12.2%), the U.S. (14.5%) and Canada (15.0%). The number of Indian women in middle and senior management roles is not much higher.

Meanwhile, the latest employment data show that worker participation (the ratio of workers to population) fell to 39.2% in 2009-2010 from 42% in 2004-2005. While the decline is marginal for men — from 55.9% to 55% — it is significant in the case of women — from 29.4% to 23.3%. Analysts say that one reason for this is that as men in the family start earning more, women, especially in the lower middle class, opt out of the work force for reasons of social status. In his column in the daily newspaper Times of India, Swaminathan Anklesaria Aiyer noted: “Social mores, especially in the lower middle class, give superior social status to households where women don’t work. When a family with rising income decides to keep females at home, it literally buys social status with the income foregone.”

But the survey’s implications go beyond individuals or families. All of this has wide ramifications for India’s continued economic growth. If the support structure and attitudes towards women, both in the workplace and in society at large, don’t change, women will either simply opt out of the workforce or — faced with endless stress — be far less productive than their true potential. This will result in a sharp blow to the country’s demographic dividend, which though touted as a key factor in India’s growth, is under its own stress. The window for growth is small and, as Ravichandar points out: “Having women as part of your workforce is no longer a nice-to-do but a must-do.”

This entry was posted in Human Resources and tagged , , , , . Bookmark the permalink. Follow any comments here with the RSS feed for this post.
  • http://twitter.com/singhshaiv Shaivalini Singh

    Truth is the mindset, unless that undergoes change even working will not solve the stress.
    At work place women are just women, and rarely taken for their being. It is the outlook so ingrained in our culture that is a challenge.

  • http://www.facebook.com/mundasinghc Mundasingh Choudhary

    @Hema Ravichandar,since you know that the reasons behind the stress on indian women are rigid policies and rewards based on effort why dont you start implementing the changes in your organisation itself ? infosys has a policy stipulating that each employee must  log  9.15 hours a day irrespective of whether he finishes the given work in 5 hours or 6 hours . Are you unaware of such meaningless policies that hold sway in your own organisation . Instead of putting the blame on society and mindsets of people , why don’t you bring in changes first in your own organisation or is it that people just talk the walk but dont walk the talk

    • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_3W4SJ7TW6K4F4MLYE54I5RXL6Y Meera

      Hema is no longer with Infosys

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Mayank-Arora/100000847300789 Mayank Arora

    Interesting!

  • PRATYUSH PUSHKAR

    India might be one of the fastest growing economies in the world but the management practices are still archaic. You “have” to stay at the office for 9hours min as time spent at office at the proxy to performance in at-least 99% of the work places.
    No flexi-time, few leaves for maternity etc. Also the need to out career ahead of your life is becoming the norm rather than the exception and women are following suit. This is followed by the typical Indian “societal” view that marriage & children are the responsibility of the women and not the man. And somewhere there, working women find themselves at cross roads and the stress becomes a way of life.
    We need to change as a society and our work places need to adapt to the same, for there is no way a nation or even a company can prosper without women excelling at work.

  • PRATYUSH PUSHKAR

    India might be one of the fastest growing economies in the world but the management practices are still archaic. You “have” to stay at the office for 9hours min as time spent at office at the proxy to performance in at-least 99% of the work places.
    No flexi-time, few leaves for maternity etc. Also the need to out career ahead of your life is becoming the norm rather than the exception and women are following suit. This is followed by the typical Indian “societal” view that marriage & children are the responsibility of the women and not the man. And somewhere there, working women find themselves at cross roads and the stress becomes a way of life.
    We need to change as a society and our work places need to adapt to the same, for there is no way a nation or even a company can prosper without women excelling at work.

  • PRATYUSH PUSHKAR

    India might be one of the fastest growing economies in the world but the management practices are still archaic. You “have” to stay at the office for 9hours min as time spent at office at the proxy to performance in at-least 99% of the work places.
    No flexi-time, few leaves for maternity etc. Also the need to out career ahead of your life is becoming the norm rather than the exception and women are following suit. This is followed by the typical Indian “societal” view that marriage & children are the responsibility of the women and not the man. And somewhere there, working women find themselves at cross roads and the stress becomes a way of life.
    We need to change as a society and our work places need to adapt to the same, for there is no way a nation or even a company can prosper without women excelling at work.

  • Lakshmi Sharma

    I completely agree with this. Even though Indian women find themselves in very big firms and establishments, identity as working women and value for their dreams(encouragement) has to improve a lot in society. Women must be responsible for all household work and it is very hard to change the mentality of people around to understand and share the responsibility.
    Sometimes it is so hard to explain people that you end up spoiling relationships with people which I have seen in many cases. 

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_3W4SJ7TW6K4F4MLYE54I5RXL6Y Meera

    Very valid points. For a moment, keep aside women, let us ask ourselves as to how many roles have we created. Take an example of IT industry, most of the companies have conventional roles like technical or managerial. Very few companies have sales, pre-sales, solution, marketing etc which are limited in number.
    Take another section, while we expect people to operate round the clock (normal Indian working hours, night teleconference with Global interfaces), have we ever come up with part time roles, specialized roles, sharing roles etc ? You will have to sustain the resistance for so long that one wonders as to the objective of battling, obviously not for self, but for the organization.
    How often do we see hype of work pressure vs the actual work ? Don’t you see redundancy, unnecessary urgency, inability to prioritize or understand the context that creates this hype of pressure. Typically, if so many had actual pressure as the hype projects, the advancement, depth & quality would have significantly improved.
    Now, coming to women as stressed individual, wouldn’t she have found a productive and less stressed environment if she had been given any one of the options provided above.
    India is more than 30 years old in the IT sector, what are we trying to depict ourselves. We are unable to innovate roles, accommodate diversity, incapable of addressing our own market with the technological advancement (growing gap rags-riches), killing agriculture ….
    Similar stories in other segments also, currently more depressing, since we were veterans in the past.

  • Anonymous

    All the comments given in the articles are valid.  But the commentators are also responsible to the problems in their own organizations. 
    In our country communication is always top down and commands also follow suit. Peer level communication on the professional front is minimal except for profession/ technical purpose. Bottom up response survey is rarely done.  So when ever it is done they always end up as complaints and demands. Women with their dual roles as family central and professional worker faces larger problems in this circumstances than the men counterparts. Few successful women, in order to circumvent this stress adapt a commandeer attitude and survive. 

  • Tamal Roy

    The study seems to be only in urban areas and in that only of middle/high income working women. To know India one must travel across rural areas, feel the pulse and not by answers to a set of questions as done in any study. Poor by appearance may be, Indian woman is still Devi( Goddess), the Shakti, who is stress buster not under stress. The basic reason of stress in urban working women is due to platonic need in their life. I would like the study group to visit rural and poor slum areas and get re-opinionated after seeing smiling faces..